Home About Services Jurisdictions Insights FAQs Contact Us Client Login Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Get a Quote →
Home › Insights › Patent Litigation and Public Procurement in Southeast Asia: When Government Contracts Create IP Risk
11/19/2026 11:36 AM

Patent Litigation and Public Procurement in Southeast Asia: When Government Contracts Create IP Risk

Introduction : Government projects in Southeast Asia routinely bundle patented equipment, software, telecommunications standards, grid systems, renewable-energy technology and integrated digital platforms into a single contract. Patent exposure may therefore arise not from the supplier’s own technology but from third-party components, subcontractors, open-source software, customer specifications, system integrations and the procuring entity’s post-delivery use or modification. Because a claim may surface years after completion, when redesign is costly and recourse against upstream vendors is limited, the risk is structurally back-loaded.

This blog analyses how tender documents allocate that risk, compares regional frameworks, reviews relevant authorities and proposes a bidder’s playbook. It argues that IP risk in public procurement is a commercial, contractual and jurisdiction-specific issue to be managed before award, not a litigation problem after delivery.

Legal Provisions

A. The Philippines

Republic Act No. 9184 (2003) has been replaced by the New Government Procurement Act, Republic Act No. 12009, signed on 20 July 2024. The Philippine Bidding Documents prepared under the regime commonly require the supplier to indemnify the procuring entity against third-party claims of patent, trademark or industrial-design infringement arising from use of the goods in the Philippines.

B. Regional Frameworks

Singapore’s Government Procurement Act 1997 and Government Procurement Regulations 2014 govern procurement conduct, while Sections 55 to 58 of the Patents Act 1994 regulate use of patented inventions by the Government. Malaysia’s Patents Act 1983 limits patent rights by reference to the rights of the Government under Section 84. Indonesia’s procurement is governed by Presidential Regulation No. 16 of 2018, as amended, and its Patent Law No. 13 of 2016 allows government implementation of patents under Articles 109 to 120 and Presidential Regulation No. 77 of 2020. Thailand’s Patent Act B.E. 2522 (1979) permits government use for public benefit under Section 51. Vietnam’s Intellectual Property Law, as amended by Law No. 131/2025/QH15 with effect from 1 April 2026, retains civil and administrative enforcement routes. Each regime must be read against Article 31 of the TRIPS Agreement, which conditions non-voluntary use on authorisation and remuneration.

Patent Litigation

Legal Analysis

A. Warranty, Indemnity, Licence and Disclosure

Tender documents often conflate four distinct instruments. A warranty is a contractual assurance whose breach sounds in damages irrespective of fault; an indemnity allocates the loss flowing from a third-party claim, often without proof of breach and frequently without a cap; a licence is a permission, and pass-through rights determine whether the procuring entity may lawfully use embedded third-party technology; and a disclosure obligation concerns accuracy of information supplied, with misstatement creating independent liability. An unqualified promise that a product will not infringe any patent anywhere is hazardous because infringement is territorial and does not depend on knowledge, so the supplier effectively warrants the unknowable state of every patent register. Assurances should be confined to the tendered configuration, specified jurisdictions, intended use and information reasonably known at bid stage.

B. Government Use as a Narrow Exception

It is tempting to assume that government-use and compulsory-licensing provisions shield suppliers. They do not operate as general defences. They require specific authorisation, are subject to remuneration, and are conceived as public-interest or emergency exceptions. Comparatively, 28 U.S.C. § 1498 substitutes government liability for that of an authorised contractor, whereas none of the regimes surveyed above clearly extends equivalent protection to private suppliers, so the contract becomes the sole protective instrument. Even where a procuring entity is protected, a contractual indemnity may still oblige the supplier to bear the patentee’s claim. Procuring entities counter that broad indemnities are necessary to protect public funds; the better view is that unlimited indemnities deter competent bidders and are priced into bids regardless.

C. Contemporary Risk Drivers

Standard-essential patents (SEPs) are central for telecommunications and connected infrastructure, and Thailand’s growing FRAND policy attention reflects this. Open-source licences and source-code escrow demands raise copyleft and trade-secret questions, and customised public-sector software in Indonesia may attract disclosure or escrow obligations. Export controls, such as Singapore’s Strategic Goods (Control) Act 2002, and localisation requirements fragment supply chains and may force substitution of components whose patent position was never assessed.

Relevant Case Laws

Unwired Planet International Ltd v. Huawei Technologies Co Ltd, [2020] UKSC 37: The UK Supreme Court held that courts may determine global FRAND licence terms. The decision shows that a SEP claim attached to one deployment can yield multi-jurisdictional royalty exposure.

Huawei Technologies Co Ltd v. ZTE Corp, Case C-170/13, EU:C:2015:477: The Court of Justice prescribed sequential steps of notice, offer and counter-offer before an SEP holder seeks injunctive relief. Suppliers should document good-faith licensing conduct.

Smith Kline Beckman Corp. v. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 126627 (Philippines, 14 August 2003): The Philippine Supreme Court applied the doctrine of equivalents, confirming that infringement is not confined to literal copying and that substitutions of components may still infringe.

Practical Implications

A bidder’s playbook begins before bidding. The supplier should map the IP chain; identify licensed, subcontracted and open-source technology; define the protected use; and negotiate exclusions for customer modifications, combinations and out-of-scope deployment. Contractually, it should retain control of defence and settlement, require prompt notice and cooperation, adopt tiered remedies (design-around, replacement, licence, refund or termination), and cap indemnities where possible. Commercially, it should price IP risk into the bid, verify insurance coverage, protect source code and trade secrets, and plan for maintenance, upgrades and newly asserted patents after delivery.

The Philippine transition under RA 12009 offers an opportunity to revisit standard risk allocation, since uniform bidding documents determine the terms on which smaller suppliers participate.

Conclusion

Public procurement converts private patent risk into contract risk, and the allocation chosen at tender stage determines who bears it years later. Suppliers should replace unqualified non-infringement promises with scoped assurances, and policymakers should consider balanced indemnity templates with tiered remedies and reasonable caps, which would improve competition without leaving patentees unprotected.

Author :- Taskin Akhtar, in case of any query, contact us at Global Patent Filing or write back us via email at support@globalpatentfiling.com.

← Back to All Insights