The Cost of Innovation: Weighing the Pros and Cons of Patenting
Innovations are the blood of the progress to bring advancements in everything possible through the scientific, technological, medical, and industrial development. Indeed, the journey from a novel idea to a commercial product is full of obstacles; one of the most critical decisions that an innovator must take is whether to patent an invention. Patenting comes with quite significant benefits but also comes with considerable costs and complexities. The rest of this blog post will describe the pros and cons of patenting in further detail, ensuring that innovators make informed decisions about protecting intellectual property.
Patenting a newly invented article secures for a limited period (generally for 20 years) the exclusive right to own the invention on the part of the inventor or patentee. One is prohibited from creating, utilizing for his own use, importing, or selling his innovation, without an authorization. In order to patent an innovation, the applicant must file an appropriate patent office application to protect the concept. Likewise, a patent applicant must describe the way the invention works and demonstrate factors such as being ingenious, useful, and non obvious.
Patenting of innovation comes out with several benefits such as safeguarding your competitiveness, boosting reputation, cash revenue, and getting access to funds or support. A patent can deny your competition from copying or imitating your innovation. It sends signals of your expertise, creativity, and quality to the customers, partners, and investors. It can allow you to sell or license your innovation to others and raise the probability of receiving grants, loans, or subsidies for your innovations.
Multinationals protect inventions through patents; however, this solution is not universal and depends on the type of business goals, strategies, forms, and progress of innovations of a given organization as well as the competition and type of industry faced. Therefore, you have to consider the aspects of patenting from the vision, mission, and objectives defined, and thus, assess the nature, scope, and value of the innovation. You will also establish how feasible and scalable the innovation meets market needs and demands. Last but not least, you have to examine the whole-sized analysis of the given market, its structure, and the dynamics of an analysis towards identifying competitor strategies and how their patenting can help the organization differentiate and compete. Patenting your innovation can work against the whole protection of intellectual property and leverage advantage over competition; however, it does entail costs, risks, and restrictions, which need careful thought. Understanding the merits and drawbacks of patenting as related to your company context and your business goals, therefore, allow one to make an informed decision and in line with one's needs-challenges in innovation.
Types of Patent
1. Utility Patent
Utility patents are an extremely common patent type, and comprise the bulk of applications filed. Such patents protect new inventions or discoveries that are useful, as described below:
Processes: Ways of doing something, such as a new method of manufacturing a product or conducting business newly.
Machines: Any apparatus or device for performing a specific function, such as engines, computers, or medical devices.
Compositions of Matter: New compositions, new chemical compositions, or compositions such as drugs and materials.
Improvements: Improvements over such previous inventions can be patented.
To qualify for a utility patent, the innovation must be novel and non-obvious, and also somewhat useful. This type of patent, as everybody knows, lasts for 20 years from the date of filing and at the expiration of that period, the patent goes into the public domain.
Design Patents
Design patents protect only the ornamental design of a functional item and exclude its utility. Aesthetic features-the shape, surface ornamentation, and overall appearance of a particular object-are typified as follows: for instance:
The unique shape of a smartphone.
The furniture's design or utility items.
Packaging's visible appearance.
In essence, the design patent must be new, original, and nonobvious. In contrast to utility patents, a design patent only lasts for about *15 years* from the date of grant. Importance of acquisition of a design patent is most relevant to organizations making products in which appearance is primary, as this deciding factor in selection by customers.
Plant Patents
Plant patents exist for the purposes of protecting new varieties of plants that can be asexually reproduced. Such techniques include reproduction from cuttings or grafts; that is, not by seed. Such things include:
New varieties of flowers.
Fruit-bearing plants with unusual characteristics.
Ornamental plants having unique features.
Plant must be asexually reproduced and different from all known varieties in order for it to qualify for a plant patent. Such a patent, like all utility patents, runs for 20 years as of the date of filing.
[Image Sources: Shutterstock]
Provisional Patents
This does not constitute a major patent type, but it is a note on provisional patents. A provisional patent application gives the inventor an early filing date but he has the full year's time to submit the full utility application. For the inventor who needs that little bit of added time to really develop or seek that funding for his creation, it really is a life saver.
Each serves a different purpose and comes with its own requirements regarding novelty and non-obviousness. By utilizing the appropriate type of patent, inventors are effective in guarding their innovations. They do this by following the complexities of patent law.Whether you are developing a new technology, creating an aesthetically pleasing product design, or cultivating a unique plant variety, securing the right patent can provide significant competitive advantages in the marketplace.
Pros of Patenting
I. Exclusive Rights
By the exclusive rights given by patents, inventors keep others from the use of their inventions. Thus, there is that a competitive edge-much in the market will be gained by the patent. The inventor will manage all profit benefits maximally and be a leader in the field by controlling usages of the invention.
II. Attracting Funding
Fundraising has become one of the significant challenges in the development of a startup or an entrepreneur. With a patent portfolio, businesses tend to attract investments to some degree as it demonstrates the uniqueness of the company's products along with their protection from competition. They have also shown that such firms tend to attract investments because shareholders will most likely invest in such ventures that care more about intellectual property rights. Thus, risk relative to returns is considerably reduced, and chances for more returns are high.
III. Licensing Opportunities
It becomes a powerful area for income through licensing. Inventors license their patents for some payment to other companies for letting the companies use the technology in return. This is useful for small businesses or an individual inventor who does not have enough resources to manufacture and market their inventions independently. Through licensing, a continual inflow of returns is assured and, at the same time, further dissemination of the invention.
IV. R&D Incentives
Patent rights encourage financing from companies for research and development purposes. These motivate companies to find new ideas and technologies since they will be granted exclusive rights over the innovation. With such assurances, the fear of originality stealing by competitors is less, and this creates an innovative culture across the different industries which will eventually develop into creating valuable discoveries and inventions.
V. Improved Market Position
Patents provide an improved positioning for a company in the market by enhancing its credibility as the innovator in the field. This, in turn, adds to brand loyalty and trustworthiness among customers as most consumers believe that patented technologies stand for quality and reliability.
Cons of Patenting
A. High Cost of Patents
They are most useful, but may be beyond reach to many because of the expensive costs involved in acquiring and maintaining a patent. Such include, but are not limited to the patent filing fee, attorney fee in preparing and prosecuting the application, maintenance fees throughout the lifespan of the patent as well as any litigation costs to be incurred whenever enforcement becomes compulsory. This can easily crush any start-up or an individual inventor.
Here are some of them, though not limited to:
Fees for Filing: Varies from one jurisdiction to another but lies between $200 and $3,000.
Attorney Fees: The range of attorney fees for preparing a utility patent application varies between $5,000 and well over $15,000.
Maintenance Fees: Charged at intervals (generally after every 3 to 4 years) succeeding patent grant. These charges get higher after some time.
B. Complicated Application Process
Patenting may take time, at times very complicated before it is finally granted. It comprises various stages, such as prior art searches, writing descriptions and claims of the invention in sufficient detail, filing with the appropriate government agency (such as the United States Patent and Trademark Office), and responding to any objections or rejections by patent examiners.
Such could delay time in coming to market for innovations. Sometimes it takes several years before a patent is issued, during which time competitors could have created competing products or technologies.
C. Difficulties in Enforcement
Even with the granting of patent rights, it becomes hard at times to enforce it against violations. It is up to the patent holder to monitor marketplaces where infringement might occur and to proceed to litigation if that is what they require. Litigation costs a lot, and is n-time consuming; many firms end up losing resources in litigations and still do not win.
Enforcement dissimilarities run high across jurisdictions; while some nations may not have such effective legal frameworks to guard patent rights, inventors can become stranded in situations of rights infringement internationally.
D. Limited Period
Patents are not endless; they can only be valid for a maximum of 20 years from the date of application (even a lesser time of 14 years, if within the case of design patents). After this limited duration of rights by the new inventor for the first time, anyone else can take, practice, and use the invention without permission from that new inventor. By the same token, these limits urge an inventor to gain profits into a considerably brief period.
E. Potentially Decreased Cooperation
The existence of patents in some cases may completely block collaboration between two industries rather than partnering the companies together on certain other complementary technologies or innovations. Many companies will not prefer to share details or work in collaboration for joint projects because they are afraid of losing control over their patented technology.
Balancing Innovation with Protection
Having weighed the pros and cons above, the innovators must be careful in deciding whether or not to seek patent protection for their inventions.
1. Assess Market Potential: Determine whether your invention really has commercial potential worth charging a patent for.
2. Perform Prior Art Searches: Conduct thorough searches of existing patents and technologies to ensure that before filing a patent the invention is truly novel.
3. Explore Other Avenues of Protection: Trade secrets or non-disclosure agreements may suffice without the expense of patents in some situations.
4. Seek Professional Guidance: The opinion of an intellectual property attorney is helpful to decide whether go for a patent under the circumstances.
The decision to patent an invention is not a blanket solution; it needs to be made very carefully considering the advantages and disadvantages in the specific case of each inventor. Patents will confer exclusive rights that may improve a market position and secure investments; however, they are typically expensive and complex, and not suitable for all innovators.
Ultimately, weighing these factors against personal goals-whether to maximize profits via exclusive rights or to engender collaboration within an industry-will guide inventors toward informed decisions regarding how best to protect their intellectual property while continuing to drive innovation forward.
In an ever-evolving landscape where technological advancements shape our world daily, understanding the cost of innovation through patenting becomes crucial not only for individual success but also for fostering an environment conducive to collective progress in society at large.
Author : ISHA ANSHUL GUPTA, in case of any query, contact us at Global Patent Filing or write back us via email at support@globalpatentfiling.com.
References
1. R. B. S. et al., Innovation Assessment Through Patent Analysis, RESEARCHGATE (2010),
2. LexisNexis, Patent Analysis: Leveraging IP Insights to Reinforce Business Decisions, LEXISNEXIS (2021),
3. J.D. Houvener, What Costs Are Involved in Obtaining a Patent?, LINKEDIN (2021),
4. LinkedIn User, What Are the Benefits and Drawbacks of Patenting Your Innovations?, LINKEDIN (2021),
5. Economics Observatory, What Can We Learn About Patents and Innovation from the Past?, ECONOMICS OBSERVATORY (2021),
6. Greyb, Patent Cost, GREYB (2021),